Comic Book Legal Defense Fund

Main menu

Skip to content
  • Contribute
    • Membership
    • Donate
    • Renew Today
    • Volunteer
  • About
    • F.A.Q.
    • Contact
    • Staff
    • CBLDF Boards
    • Bylaws
    • Corporate Members
    • Retail Members
  • Resources
    • Media
      • CBLDF Defender
      • Radio Free Comix: The CBLDF Podcast
      • Downloads
    • Banned Comics: Case Files
    • Diverse Voices
      • She Changed Comics
      • Profiles in Black Cartooning
    • Customs
    • The Comics Code
    • History of Comics Censorship
    • Case Files
      • CBLDF Case Files
        • CBLDF Case Files – R. v. Matheson
        • CBLDF Case Files – U.S. v. Handley
        • CBLDF Case Files — Brown v. EMA
        • CBLDF Case Files – Georgia v. Gordon Lee
        • CBLDF Case Files – Top Shelf v. U.S. Customs
        • CBLDF Case Files — Kraft Foods v. Helm
        • CBLDF Case Files – Texas v. Castillo
        • CBLDF Case Files — Starbucks v. Dwyer
        • CBLDF Case Files – Winter Bros. v. DC Comics
        • CBLDF Case Files – Oklahoma v. Planet Comics
        • CBLDF Case Files – Florida v. Mike Diana
        • CBLDF Case Files – California BOE v. Paul Mavrides
        • CBLDF Case Files — Illinois v. Correa
          • People v. Correa
      • Obscenity Case Files
        • Obscenity Case Files: People of New York v. Kirkpatrick (Zap Comix #4)
        • Obscenity Case Files: FCC v. Pacifica Foundation (George Carlin’s Seven Dirty Words)
        • Obscenity Case Files: United States v. One Book Called “Ulysses”
        • Obscenity Case Files: Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District
        • Obscenity Case Files: Jacobellis v. Ohio (“I know it when I see it”)
        • Obscenity Case Files: Joseph Burstyn, Inc. v. Wilson (The Mircale Decision)
        • Obscenity Case Files: Pope v. Illinois
        • Obscenity Case Files: People v. Bruce (The Lenny Bruce Trial)
      • Noteworthy Cases
        • People v. Kirkpatrick
          • People v. Kirkpatrick, Criminal Court of NY (1970)
          • People v. Kirkpatrick, NY State Court of Appeals (1973)
        • Miller v. California
    • Manga
      • Criminal Prosecutions of Manga
      • Manga Book Club Handbook
    • Further Reading
    • Webinars
  • Library & Educator Tools
    • Adding Graphic Novels to Your Library or Classroom Collection
    • Book Clubs
    • Panel Power
    • Raising a Reader! How Comics & Graphic Novels Can Help Your Kids Love To Read!
    • Using Graphic Novels in Education
    • CBLDF Discussion Guides
    • CBLDF Banned Books Week Handbook
    • Be Heard: Youth Protest Rights Primer
    • Know Your Rights: Student Rights Fact Sheet
    • 2019 Comics in Education Survey
    • CBLDF Certified Stores
    • Working With Libraries! A Handbook For Comics Creators
    • Graphic Novels: Suggestions for Librarians
  • Retailer Tools
    • Coronavirus Resources
    • Social Media and Digital Resources
    • Book Club and Community Resources
    • Free Retailer Webinars
    • Know Your Rights
  • Rewards
    • Membership
    • Premiums
    • CBLDF at Teespring
  • Report Censorship
Homepage, News Blog

Pearls Before Swine: A Quick Look at Editorial Discretion Versus Censorship

by Jordan Smith • January 22, 2021 • Comments Off on Pearls Before Swine: A Quick Look at Editorial Discretion Versus Censorship
Cartoon depicting the artist with the characters of his strip Pearls Before Swine
art by Stephan Pastis

This past week the comic strip syndicate Andrews McNeel pulled five strips of creator Stephan Pastis’s “Pearls Before Swine” comic, effectively removing it from 850 newspapers nationwide. A set of five replacement strips, also by Pastis, were run in their place. The strips were pulled because they dealt with a coup at the capital and would have appeared shortly after the attempted coup at our own Capitol Building. It may seem like censorship at first but, it is, in fact, an example of editorial discretion.

One of the key factors in this difference is that the strips were written well in advance on the events of January 6. Prior to the announcement of the removal of the strips, Pastis remarked in a Teet, “They were all created at least a month in advance of yesterdays events and are not a commentary on them.” Pastis later added that some of the strips were written as far back as 2017.

Something that needs to be considered as an editor is what you are releasing and to whom? Chief Executive Officer of Andrews McNeel, Andy Sareyan, remarked,

“. . . to run them now just seemed like bad timing. They were about to come out at the time when tensions are running so high in the country.”

Pastis himself supported their decision by saying,

“They are known for defending their creators against angry editors, readers, etc. But the country right now is at such a delicate inflection point. No one knows what’s going to happen.”

If we look at censorship as an act that denies information and/or the expression of ideas, we see that is not the case in the “Pearls before Swine” instance. The pulled strips are not necessarily buried. Pastis remarked they may be ready to run as soon as six months from now when there has been some distance from recent events. There is also no suppression of ideas; the strips, having been written well before the events of January 6, had no intention to become a commentary on them. The strips may resonate with recent events in a way that was not intended by the creator. This is not a case of censorship but a great example of editorial discretion.

If you are a comics art creator who needs help or advice in regards to censorship, you can reach out to CBLDF at info@cbldf.org.

Tags: Andrews McMeel Syndication censorship editorial discretion pearls before swine self-censorship stephan pastis

Post navigation

← Con Report: 9th Annual Black Comic Book Festival
CBLDF’s Comics in Education Survey Relaunches Today! →
logo
Complete Graveyard Book HC, signed by Neil Gaiman!

Vendor: Harper Collins
Type: Graphic Novels
Price: 60.00

In response to clamorous fan requests, the two volumes of the graphic novel adaptation of The Graveyard Book are now bound into one stunning edition. Nobody Owens is a normal boy, except h...

Author: CBLDF - Rewards Zone
Posted: May 6, 2021, 7:36 pm
Sandman: Overture HC, signed by Neil Gaiman!

Vendor: DC Vertigo
Type: Graphic Novels
Price: 40.00

(W) Neil Gaiman (A/CA) J. H. Williams
Twenty-five years after THE SANDMAN first changed the landscape of modern comics, Neil Gaiman's legendary series is back in a deluxe hardcover edition! ...
Author: CBLDF - Rewards Zone
Posted: May 6, 2021, 7:36 pm
Umbrella Academy Library Edition Vol 2 HC, Signed & Sketched by Gabriel Bá!

Vendor: Dark Horse
Type: Graphic Novels
Price: 50.00

(W) Gerard Way (A) Gabriel Ba

The Umbrella Academy is despondent following the near apocalypse created by one of their own and the death of their beloved mentor Pogo. Trouble is-each of them ...
Author: CBLDF - Rewards Zone
Posted: May 6, 2021, 7:34 pm
Umbrella Academy Library Edition Vol 1 HC, Signed & Sketched by Gabriel Bá!

Vendor: Dark Horse
Type: Graphic Novels
Price: 50.00

(W) Gerard Way (A) Gabriel Bá

In an inexplicable worldwide event, forty-three extraordinary children were spontaneously born by women who'd previously shown no signs of pregnancy. Millionaire ...
Author: CBLDF - Rewards Zone
Posted: May 6, 2021, 7:34 pm
The Essential Dykes to Watch Out For HC, Signed and Sketched by Alison Bechdel!

Vendor: Houghton Mifflin
Type: Graphic Novels
Price: 75.00

(W/A/CA) Alison Bechdel
For twenty-five years Bechdel's path-breaking Dykes to Watch Out For strip has been collected in award-winning volumes, syndicated in fifty alternative newspap...
Author: CBLDF - Rewards Zone
Posted: October 8, 2020, 6:36 pm
On a Sunbeam GN, Signed by Tillie Walden

Vendor: First Second
Type: Graphic Novels
Price: 30.00

An epic graphic novel about a girl who travels to the ends of the universe to find a long lost love, from acclaimed author Tillie Walden. Throughout the deepest reaches of space, a crew rebu...

Author: CBLDF - Rewards Zone
Posted: August 27, 2020, 8:04 pm

Copyright © 2023 Comic Book Legal Defense Fund. All Rights Reserved. The Magazine Basic Theme by bavotasan.com.